A sector under strain
The University of Dundee has lost 675 roles since August 2024, with 190 more job cuts announced in June despite a £40 million bailout. Aberdeen, Glasgow Caledonian, Heriot-Watt, and Strathclyde have also announced major cuts in quick succession, on top of long-running restructures at Edinburgh and Glasgow. Unions argue the root cause is funding, as Scottish universities reportedly receive around 23% less per student than their English counterparts. A joint review by the Scottish Government and Universities Scotland has since identified a structural funding gap of around £200 million.
Colleges, which deliver much of the country’s practical training, are under similar pressure. The Scottish Funding Council revealed 71% of colleges expect to operate at a deficit in 2025-26, rising to nearly 80% by 2027-28.
The Scottish Government’s pre-election budget promised universities a real-terms rise and colleges a 10% uplift; however, universities have continued to announce job cuts, while colleges cut courses and staff.
Marra argues employers are paying the price by being unable to find workers with the required skills. His most striking example is welders from South Africa and the Philippines being recruited to work on the next generation of Scottish warships, in a nation that was once renowned for its shipbuilding. He calls it a failure of Holyrood’s centralised skills policy and notes that apprenticeship funding has fallen while shortages grow.
What Marra wants to do
Marra’s approach has four strands:
- Cross-party working: Marra says Holyrood has maintained a “consensus of silence” on education and has promised to work with other parties to end it.
- Defence skills: Marra urged the Scottish Government to match the UK Government’s £10 million for defence technical colleges, which would unlock £20 million of total investment in defence skills training. On 15 October, ministers confirmed the £10 million match funding.
- Devolving skills: Marra wants skills policy pushed down to Scotland’s regions, with money and control in the hands of councils and colleges.
- A wider education reset: Marra has called for a national “renewal” of Scottish education, with knowledge restored to the curriculum alongside skills.
The Scottish Government is moving toward consolidation. Its Tertiary Education and Training (Funding and Governance) (Scotland) Act brings apprenticeship, college, and university funding under the Scottish Funding Council. Ministers say this will simplify decisions, while Marra favours pushing power downward. How these two approaches fit together will help decide who commissions and funds training.
What comes next
Labour has abstained on the Scottish Budget in each of the last two years. In the Budget 2026-27 meeting of the Parliament, Michael Marra argued the Budget did not “meet the aspirations of the people of Scotland”, explaining that £1 billion was lost to Scotland’s budget due to an economic performance gap.
The Scottish Budget will largely fund commitments the Government has already made. The SNP manifesto pledged 150,000 apprenticeships over the parliamentary term, and the Programme for Government repeated that target, added a new Apprenticeship Accelerator Grant and promised a single National Skills Plan by spring 2027. The Scottish Budget is the first real test of whether the Scottish Government will deliver on these commitments and what Labour will ask for.
The funding review is the likely route to a fix. The joint Scottish Government and Universities Scotland review published in August found a gap of around £200 million based on 2023/24 data. Its options for a new framework are likely to be published after the Budget. The review includes formal engagement with opposition parties, giving Labour a chance to make its case.
The following milestones will determine whether Marra’s argument turns into change:
- The next Budget: the test is whether the funding matches the 150,000 apprenticeship pledge and the college reforms. Marra will need to say what he would do differently with the same money. A third abstention would be hard to defend, so he is more likely to set a price, such as better apprenticeship funding.
- The funding review: the first phase set out the evidence; later phases are due to set out options for a new funding framework.
- Defence skills delivery: the £10 million match funding is confirmed, but the business case and public finance approvals are still to be completed, so the details are yet to come.
- The Scottish Government’s response: whether it matches the UK defence skills funding will be an early test of how far cross-party working can go.
- Marra’s proposals: he now needs to cost policies on universities, colleges, and apprenticeships.
In a shift from Anas Sarwar’s focus on the NHS, Marra will bring renewed attention to education and skills in Scotland. Whether he can convert this focus into influence will depend on the Budget, the funding review, and the Scottish Government’s response, but Labour’s new status as the Official Opposition gives him a stronger hand.
Track the education and skills policy and everything else that matters to you in Scottish policy and politics with our dedicated service. Find out more and register for a two-week trial.



